<The picture of Dorian Gray : Sins and
human nature>
11v2
121004 Kwon Namhyung
A
well-known story, the picture of Dorian Gray written by Oscar Wilde, is a novel
that handles issue of good and evil. The novel is semi-autobiography of author
himself, and it contains profound philosophical agony of evilness. In the
novel, picture gets wicked whenever Dorian done evil actions. Some critics
states that the picture is visual image of sin. Sins visualize in the picture
and Dorian’s face becomes disgusting. Oscar Wilde did divide good and evil and
described evil and sin as negative aspect that all human have.
Compared to the
novel “Demian”, Oscar Wilde expresses his feelings to the concept of good and
evil as two individual concepts. In Demian, Herman Hesse, claims that there is
no precise criterion of good and evil. He says that human should never be
restricted by good and evil since the concept is very vague. Oscar Wilde mainly
has very different perspective and he reflects it in his novel. Dorian meets
tragic death in the end. However, even Oscar did not mention good always win.
He divided the character into two groups; good and bad. There are some neutral
characters, but readers can consider them as good side since they did not show
any sins in the novel. Characters in the bad group, for instance, Dorian, meets
tragic end like any other novel, however, characters in the good group did not
end up living happily ever after. They all end up dying due to their weakness
compared to bad characters. Oscar’s perspective towards good and evil is not
simple as it is shown in the novel.
Oscar
Wilde introduced another concept to explain about the concept of good and evil.
The concept is beauty. In the novel Henry mentions that beauty exceeds evil. He
made a point that beauty is even better than goodness. To Lord Henry good and
evil is not the matter considering reality. To him, the real conflict is
individual and society that is surrounding him. Here, Oscar makes a point of
moral and ethics. Moral and ethics is not about good and evil when the concept
was initially raised. It was a concept to protect the surrounding society to
remain silent from one individual to ruin it. Under this concept, good and evil
does not matter anymore. Only beauty and ugly is the matter.
People call Dorian’s
attractive face a beauty of the beast. People look at the beauty firstly even
when they are looking at a beast. As the novel turns out to be a semi-biography
of author himself, Oscar Wilde thinks that beauty could exceed evil and sins
could be forgiven by beauty. However, he did admit that evilness and sins makes
beauty into a beast by describing how portrait changed. Aforementioned, the
picture is visualization of sins and Oscar did admit that beauty does not last
long in front of evilness.
I kind of see where you are going in some places, and agree wholly with your claims. Then, I am not sure where are going in other places, and I disagree wholly with your claims. So, this is a bit of a tossed salad you have here in terms of literary analysis, and what's missing from the salad is evidence from the text. Instead, you have broad generalizations and over simplified assumptions about what Wilde or Dorian etc. etc. represent or seek. You have a lot on the plate, but need a knife and fork to really access it.
답글삭제First of all, "good and bad" is very relevant to the novel, but can we divide characters into groups that are good and bad? Wilde wants them to be both, and Dorian, himself, is struggling with this. Basil, whom you don't mention, is probably the most important character is we are going to weigh good vs. evil.
Anyways, try to keep your claims focused and not overly complex, and provide evidence from the text. Your syntax as well is erratic in terms of grammar. Some sentences wonderful, followed by some that are clumsy and easy to fix if you looked carefully. Example: " In the novel, picture gets wicked whenever Dorian done evil actions." A missing article, and a verb problem. Be more meticulous and revise. MS Word will clearly indicate the problem in this sentence if you give a chance.